Courts Are Narrowing Private DNC Lawsuits: Why Calling and Texting Teams Should Keep Scrubbing
By EasyDNC ·
A run of recent federal court decisions has narrowed who can sue under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act's do-not-call provisions. On November 6, 2026, the Southern District of Texas dismissed a do-not-call claim built on text messages. A week earlier, the Middle District of Pennsylvania did the same. Defense lawyers are now pointing to a Middle District of Florida order that went further and questioned private claims tied to the National Do Not Call Registry itself.
For teams that build and scrub calling and texting lists, the obvious question is whether any of this changes the routine. It is tempting to read the headlines as permission to relax: skip the registry check on SMS campaigns, or treat wireless numbers as outside the rules. That reading gets ahead of what the courts actually decided.
This article explains what the TCPA do-not-call rulings held, what they left untouched, and why the practical standard for scrubbing should stay the same. It is written for the people who manage suppression lists for sales teams, call centers, and agencies.
Teams that scrub lists with EasyDNC can upload a file from the EasyDNC home page, check a single number with the Free Test Lookup, or connect a dialer or texting platform through the EasyDNC API.
What the Recent TCPA Do-Not-Call Rulings Held
The cases turn on one sentence. 47 U.S.C. § 227(c)(5) lets a person sue after receiving "more than one telephone call within any 12-month period" from the same entity in violation of the do-not-call regulations. Other parts of the statute use the broader term "telephone solicitation," which Congress defined as a telephone "call or message."
In Siringi v. Crust Pizza Co., the Texas court read that difference as meaningful. It followed the Seventh Circuit's 2026 decision in Steidinger v. Blackstone Medical Services and held that text messages are not "telephone calls" for the private claim in § 227(c)(5). The Middle District of Pennsylvania reached the same result in Bronstin v. Happy Cabbage Analytics on October 29, 2026, and dismissed that case with prejudice.
Two other arguments are gaining ground, as a November 16 Mintz analysis describes. Courts in Virginia and Missouri have held that wireless lines are not "residential" lines for these claims. The Florida order reasoned that the registry rules were not prescribed within the deadline Congress set in 1991, so § 227(c)(5) does not reach them.
What These Decisions Did Not Change
Every one of these rulings is about a private lawsuit. None of them changes the regulations that callers are required to follow, and none binds the agencies that enforce them. The Texas court said so directly: its conclusion about § 227(c)(5) "does not determine the validity of an otherwise applicable FCC regulation."
The FCC's rule at 47 C.F.R. § 64.1200(c)(2) still prohibits telephone solicitations to numbers on the national registry. Paragraph (e) of the same section still applies the registry and company-specific rules to "telemarketing calls or text messages to wireless telephone numbers." The FTC's Telemarketing Sales Rule also still treats a call to a registered number as an abusive practice, unless an exception such as written agreement or an established business relationship applies.
Federal enforcement continues as well. The FTC's actions against telemarketers and the platforms that support them do not depend on whether a private plaintiff could have sued. A court ruling that narrows a private claim does nothing to reduce that exposure.
The Court Split Is Real, and It Cuts Both Ways
These decisions are not the final word. In Siringi itself, the court declined to follow an earlier decision from the same district, Alvarez v. Fiesta Nissan, which held that texts do count as calls. Other courts, including the Northern District of California in Wilson v. MEDVIDI, have also treated texts as calls. Results can differ from one courtroom to the next, even within a single state.
For a team running national campaigns, that unpredictability is the practical problem. A contact list does not know which district a recipient lives in, and a texting platform does not route messages by circuit precedent. Building a workflow around a defense that works in some courts and fails in others means accepting risk on every campaign that reaches the rest.
The Florida order is a single district court decision. Other courts may decline to follow it, and appeals could change the picture again.
State Laws Fill the Gap
The Texas case shows how state law can survive even when the federal claim does not. The court dismissed the federal do-not-call claim but refused to dismiss the plaintiff's claim under Texas Business and Commerce Code § 305.053. That statute lets a person sue over a communication that violates § 227 "or a regulation adopted under that provision." The court reserved its ruling on that claim and ordered further briefing.
Other states have their own rules that reach texts directly. Pennsylvania's Act 47, covered in our article on Pennsylvania's new telemarketing hours and text rules, now defines a telephone solicitation to include text messages and ringless voicemail. Several states also keep their own do-not-call lists and private rights of action. A narrower federal remedy can simply move the claim into state law.
How Calling and Texting Teams Should Respond
The safest reading of these decisions is that nothing in the daily workflow should change. A few habits deserve extra attention while the law is unsettled:
- Run SMS lists through the same National Do Not Call Registry scrub as voice lists, rather than a separate, lighter process.
- Keep wireless numbers in the scrub; do not filter them out on the theory that they are not residential lines.
- Use registry data no more than 31 days old, as the Telemarketing Sales Rule's safe harbor requires, and keep records of each scrub.
- Apply one internal do-not-call file across every channel, so a stop request by text also suppresses calls.
Agencies should confirm with each client that consent records, opt-out handling, and scrub logs cover texting as fully as calling. Where a client asks to skip the registry check for an SMS campaign because of these rulings, that request is worth routing to the client's counsel before any messages go out.
The opt-out side matters too. The FCC rules that take effect on November 25, explained in our article on FCC opt-out rules for calling teams, apply to calls and texts alike and are not affected by these cases.
Documentation Is the Common Thread
Whether a dispute comes from a regulator, a state attorney general, or a private plaintiff, the first question is usually the same: what process did the business use? The Telemarketing Sales Rule's safe harbor rests on written procedures, trained staff, a current registry version, and records that show the process ran.
That record is valuable in any court, regardless of how the text-message question is ultimately resolved. A dated scrub file, a consistent internal list, and a clear consent trail support a defense on the merits. They do not depend on persuading a judge to adopt a particular reading of § 227(c)(5).
A Steady Standard While the Law Shifts
Court decisions on the TCPA will keep arriving, and some will favor callers while others favor consumers. Teams that rebuild their process each time a ruling makes headlines end up with gaps between channels, clients, and states.
The steadier approach is to treat the registry rules as written: scrub every telemarketing list, voice and text, against current registry data, honor every opt-out across channels, and keep the records. That standard holds up whichever way the next ruling goes.
This is general information, not legal advice. Court decisions in this area are changing, and requirements vary by call type, state, and business, so confirm your obligations with qualified counsel or your compliance team.
This article is general information, not legal advice.